Excelsior Installer vs. Alternatives: Which Is Right for You?Choosing the right installer for your software can make distribution, updates, and user experience far smoother — or create friction that costs time and reputation. This article compares Excelsior Installer with several common alternatives, highlights strengths and weaknesses, and gives practical guidance to help you pick the best option for your project.
What is Excelsior Installer?
Excelsior Installer is a commercial installer authoring tool designed to build professional installation packages for desktop applications. It typically targets Windows (MSI, EXE) and may include features such as customizable UI, dependency checks, automated updates, and support for scripting and advanced installation logic. Its focus is on delivering polish and reliability for commercial software distribution.
Common alternatives
- Windows Installer (MSI) & WiX Toolset
- Inno Setup
- NSIS (Nullsoft Scriptable Install System)
- InstallShield
- Squirrel and WinSparkle-style auto-updaters (for app-specific update workflows)
- Cross-platform packaging tools (Electron-builder for Electron apps, Homebrew/cask for macOS, Snap/Flatpak for Linux)
Comparison criteria
When evaluating installers, consider these factors:
- Compatibility (platforms and OS versions supported)
- Package type (MSI, EXE, DMG, PKG, single-file bundles)
- Customization and UI control
- Scripting and advanced install logic (custom actions, registry edits, service installation)
- Digital signing and security support
- Update/patching mechanism and delta updates
- Size and performance of generated installers
- Licensing and cost (open-source vs commercial)
- Community, documentation, and support
Feature-by-feature comparison
| Feature / Tool | Excelsior Installer | WiX (MSI) | Inno Setup | NSIS | InstallShield | Squirrel / App updater |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primary target | Windows (commercial focus) | Windows MSI | Windows | Windows | Windows (enterprise) | App-specific auto-updates |
| Package types | EXE, MSI (often) | MSI | EXE | EXE | MSI/EXE | App updater frameworks |
| GUI customization | High | Moderate (with extensions) | High | Moderate | High | Limited (focus on auto-update) |
| Scripting / custom actions | Yes (advanced) | Yes (custom actions) | Pascal scripting | Script-based | Yes (extensive) | Programmatic updates |
| Digital signing support | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Auto-update capability | Varies (often included) | Requires extra work | Requires add-ons | Requires add-ons | Often integrated | Built-in (for apps) |
| Cost / license | Commercial | Open-source | Open-source | Open-source | Commercial | Usually open-source / library-based |
| Learning curve | Moderate | Steep (XML-based) | Low to moderate | Moderate | Steep | Low for integration |
Strengths of Excelsior Installer
- Polished output and professional-looking installers suitable for commercial distribution.
- Strong GUI customization allowing branded, user-friendly setups.
- Built-in tools for dependency checks and pre-install validation.
- Vendor support and documentation aimed at enterprise customers.
- Often bundles conveniences like update support, signing integration, and telemetry hooks (configurable).
Strengths of alternatives
- WiX Toolset: Best for strict MSI-compliant installers and enterprise deployment scenarios (Group Policy, SCCM). Highly configurable and integrates well with build pipelines, but requires familiarity with XML and MSI concepts.
- Inno Setup: Great balance of power and simplicity — small installer sizes, easy scripting (Pascal), large community, fast to author. Ideal for many desktop apps where MSI is not required.
- NSIS: Very scriptable and lightweight, good for custom installer logic and small-size installers; steeper scripting for complex UI.
- InstallShield: Feature-rich for enterprise with advanced support and GUI tools; expensive licensing but powerful for large vendors.
- Squirrel / app updaters: Best for apps needing seamless in-app updates (especially desktop apps built with frameworks like Electron or .NET). Not intended as full-featured installer authors.
When to choose Excelsior Installer
Choose Excelsior Installer if you need:
- A polished, branded installer for commercial distribution with professional support.
- Built-in features (dependency checks, update support) without assembling many separate tools.
- Vendor-backed support and an easier path to enterprise distribution when you prefer a GUI-driven authoring experience over scripting/config files.
- A solution where you prefer licensing a commercial product for guaranteed maintenance and compatibility.
When to choose an alternative
Choose a different tool when:
- You need a pure MSI for enterprise deployment (use WiX).
- You want a free, lightweight, easily scriptable installer with small output size (use Inno Setup or NSIS).
- You need deep integration with continuous integration/build systems and total control over MSI internals (WiX).
- You require full enterprise feature set and vendor ecosystem and can afford the cost (InstallShield).
- Your app benefits from integrated in-app updating rather than a separate installer (Squirrel, electron-updater, etc.).
Practical decision checklist
- Target environment: MSI required by IT departments? Choose WiX or InstallShield.
- Budget: open-source tools (Inno, NSIS, WiX) vs. commercial (Excelsior, InstallShield).
- User experience: need polished branded UI and fewer manual scripts? Consider Excelsior or InstallShield.
- Update model: need built-in auto-update? Consider Squirrel-style updaters or an installer with integrated update support.
- Build pipeline integration: ensure the tool supports automated headless builds and signing.
- Support & maintenance: prefer vendor support and SLAs? Favor commercial offerings.
Example scenarios
- Indie dev with small Windows app, limited budget: Inno Setup — quick, free, customizable, small installers.
- Enterprise software needing MSI and Group Policy deployment: WiX (or InstallShield if budget allows).
- Cross-platform Electron app needing seamless updates: Squirrel/electron-updater (or platform-specific package + updater).
- Commercial software distributed to end users with brand expectations and vendor support: Excelsior Installer or InstallShield.
Final recommendation
If your priorities are polished user experience, vendor support, and an all-in-one commercial solution, Excelsior Installer is a strong choice. If you need strict MSI compliance, low cost, or maximum scripting control, consider WiX, Inno Setup, or NSIS depending on your technical and budget constraints. For seamless in-app updates, prefer an app-update framework.
Leave a Reply